SealLink Open Questions and Provisional Parameters
- Version:
1.0.0-draft.2 - Purpose: Authoritative registry of every unresolved design item, provisional numeric constant, deferred extension, and unprofiled standard service type. Per
SPEC-00 §5.1, readers MUST fail closed on any unprofiledopenconstruct.
1. Open Normative Profiles and Protocols
| ID | Owning Spec | Status | Topic | Current Safe Fallback / Blocking Scope |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OQ-001 | SPEC-04 §4 (SL-ORIG-010) | open | Trusted calendar time-interval oracle for human majority boundary T ([t_low, t_high]). | Fail closed (GUARDIAN_TIME_BOUNDARY) whenever credible UTC bounds cannot be established or straddle T. Candidate profiles: multi-source Roughtime / signed NTS quorum + chain MTP floor. |
OQ-002 | SPEC-02 §1.1 (SL-LDGR-002) | open | Tier 2 light / proof-bundle verifier profile (k >= 2 independent UTXO/name proof servers or future authenticated UTXO commitments). | Tier 1 full-node verifier is required for all effect executors. Tier 2 is deferred to post-v1.0. |
OQ-003 | SPEC-06 §6 (SL-GRNT-014) | open | External CAS witness wire protocol (advance(journal_id, token, pos, from_commit, to_commit)). | State machine and fencing invariants are decided; interoperable wire transport (e.g., HTTP CAS / Raft / consensus-backed service) remains operator-local until profiled. |
OQ-004 | SPEC-03 §4 (SL-IDEN-009) | open | **HTTPS .well-known domain-binding verification** (Channel 2 pairing between id/<label> and d/<label> or DNSSEC/NIP-05). | Channel 0 (inline) and Channel 1 (local cache / configured mirrors) work unconditionally; Channel 2 is optional and hash-pinned only. |
OQ-005 | SPEC-01 §4.1 (SL-WIRE-012) | open | Additional hardware device algorithms (fido2-es256, fido2-eddsa, ssh-ed25519 WebAuthn/SSH wrappers). | v1.0 closes DeviceList.alg to bip340, p256, and ed25519. Hardware wrapper formats will be proposed via SLIPs with exact canonical challenge framing. |
OQ-006 | SPEC-02 §6.3 (SL-LDGR-013) | open | **Production propagation qualification for TRUC v3 / P2A (51024e73) CPFP revocation.** | Two-node Namecoin Core nc28.0 regtest 1p1c submitpackage + P2P propagation + confirmation is verified (conformance/p2a-regtest/, covering minrelaytxfee = 0.001 NMC/1000 vB and 240-sat P2A dust floor). Independent operator administration, fee competition, and mainnet propagation remain open before chain-tested maturity. |
OQ-007 | SPEC-02 §3.1 (SL-LDGR-004), SPEC-04 §3.1 | open | **Threshold ECDSA (P2WPKH / single-key branch) operational qualification.** | Native P2WSH m-of-n via namepsbt is the primary v1.0 threshold custody path for name outputs (nc28.0 standard policy). Institutional single-key roles (disposer_pk, arbiter_pk, challenger_pk, single-key P2WPKH seals) require external threshold ECDSA signing qualification if shared across multiple operators. |
2. Provisional Numeric Constants (Subject to Empirical Calibration Before Freeze)
| ID | Owning Spec | Constant | Provisional Value | Calibration Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OQ-010 | SPEC-02 §4 (SL-LDGR-008) | LAG (reading-node header lag bound) | 1 block | Namecoin block propagation telemetry. |
OQ-011 | SPEC-02 §4 (SL-LDGR-008) | S (block header future-timestamp bound) | 600 seconds | Namecoin consensus vs clock skew tolerances. |
OQ-012 | SPEC-02 §4 (SL-LDGR-008) | K (grant recent_block recency ceiling) | 432 blocks (~72 h) | Issuance ceremony offline signing latency vs replay window. |
OQ-013 | SPEC-02 §4 (SL-LDGR-008) | Risk Class 1 / Class 2 tip_age cutoffs | 3600s / 5400s | Namecoin block-interval tail distribution (9.88 min mean). |
OQ-014 | SPEC-03 §6 (SL-IDEN-012) | Host trust-root admin override delay D | 1008 blocks (~7 d) | Incident response window for human owners. |
OQ-015 | SPEC-04 §6 (SL-ORIG-013) | Dual-party name_recovery minimum delay | 144 blocks min (1008 recommended) | Live-owner liveness & cancellation window. |
3. Unprofiled Standard Service Types (registry/service-types.json)
The following standard service_type names are reserved with status = "open" pending dedicated SLIP profiles meeting the SPEC-07 §4.1 checklist:
service_type | Planned Profile | Notes |
|---|---|---|
xmpp | PROFILE-xmpp-v1.md | Sovereign XMPP hosting bound via manifest.providers[]. |
blob | PROFILE-blob-v1.md | Grant-aware content-addressed blob store (Blossom BUD-01/02/04). |
wallet | PROFILE-wallet-v1.md | seallink/coins spend & budget execution (concrete executor, UTXO seal, no bearer sessions). |
names | PROFILE-names-v1.md | Delegated update-only ledger name operations. |
compute | PROFILE-compute-v1.md | Metered LLM/compute proxy (seallink/cost, seallink/tokens, root window_only, bearer sessions). |
rental | PROFILE-rental-v1.md | Contract-bound physical/digital asset lease (requires_contract = true, arbiter seal). |
4. Institutional and Scope Boundaries Explicitly Outside v1.0
- Reversible adult legal capacity (conservatorship): v1.0 enforces strictly one-way
ward -> autonomous. Reversible capacity requires a future SLIP addressing judicial contestation and revocation of autonomy. - Cross-chain bridge semantics: v1.0 binds one
network+genesisper object and verification session.